About Me - Anthony “Malum”
I’ve been casting since 2016. I spent my first two years learning the craft before transitioning into audio editing and production work behind the scenes for both esports and podcasting. In 2022, I returned to casting, and in 2024 I signed a contract to cast for Hi-Rez Studios’ SMITE 1 and SMITE 2.
Over the years I’ve cast more than ten different titles and experienced every level of the grind — from long amateur broadcast days covering upwards of fifteen matches in a single day, to stretches of six best-of-fives across five days during community events. My proudest accomplishment so far has been casting the SMITE 2 Founders Series LAN in Las Vegas.
I’ve also been incredibly lucky to learn from and receive advice from some extremely talented people throughout the years and to this day. Starting with my very first lessons from Verbalosity, and continuing through conversations and guidance from names like Fdot, Goremiser, Aggro, Dolson, Jorby, JMac, Hinduman, and many others. I am still learning and improving as we should all do. Always remember no matter how good anybody ever gets, they can ALWAYS level up and should strive to.
While these are my own thoughts and experiences, a lot of what’s in this document comes from the collective knowledge of people far better at this than I was when I started. My goal is simply to pass along the things that helped me most, along with lessons I had to learn the hard way.
Where do we start? Well, what are we trying to accomplish?
At the end of the day, casting is storytelling.
You are not there to overpower the game, dominate every second of airtime, or prove how much you know. Your job is to help elevate the moments happening on screen and make them memorable for the players and the audience watching. We are helping to entertain and inform while the players provide the magic.
Especially in the amateur scene of SMITE 2, or any game for that matter, a huge part of the experience is making players feel like they’re on the big stage. For a lot of people these tournaments and broadcasts become lasting memories. The cast should enhance those moments, not distract from them.
A good broadcast should feel natural. Fun. Conversational. Emotional when it needs to be. Quiet when it needs to be. The best casting duos build chemistry with each other while becoming the soundtrack to the game unfolding in front of them.
One of the biggest mistakes newer casters make is thinking they always need to be “on.” Constant noise does not equal a good cast. Some moments need energy, some need analysis, and some need room to breathe. Learning that balance is one of the most important skills you can develop.
Everything in this guide ultimately comes back to a few core ideas:
- chemistry
- timing
- trust in your co-caster
- understanding the flow of the game
- making the experience enjoyable for everyone involved
The goal is not perfection. The goal is creating moments people remember.
The BIG lesson. FIND THE BALL!!!!
One of the most important lessons I ever learned came from Fdot and Hinduman.
In traditional sports, there is almost always a literal ball. The audience naturally understands where to look because the ball tells the story. The caster’s job is to enhance that understanding and build tension around it.
In MOBAs and especially SMITE, there is no literal ball.
That means part of the Play-By-Play caster’s job is finding what the “ball” is during any given moment and guiding the audience toward it.
Sometimes the ball is:
- the jungler diving the backline
- a carry who is tired of losing the 1v1 and FINALLY gets the big penta
- the flank nobody sees coming from the dark horses
- the Fire Giant burn
- the health bar of a player barely surviving
- one crucial ultimate waiting to be used
Your job is not to scream every ability, read every kill feed update, or explain every particle effect happening on screen. Your job is to identify the central point of tension and build the story around it.You are there so that the person who is alt-tabbed, half paying attention has a reason to turn their head and turn up the volume. This reads like I am only referring to play-by-play, but if you have ever watched any of the chair 2’s I mentioned, you know that can be just as, if not more compelling at times.
Once you find the ball, the rest of the fight becomes easier to follow.
Pick your focus. Guide the audience through it. Then branch outward naturally as the fight develops because ultimately, casting is storytelling. And if we are not entertaining people and helping tell the story of the game, then what are we doing?
Let’s break down the cast into its phases!
Draft Phase / Picks & Bans
The draft is where the cast truly begins building the audience’s understanding of the game before anyone even loads onto the map. We’ve had our intro, done our ad reads and the fun begins. One of the biggest mistakes newer casters make is treating picks and bans like a checklist:
“Thor banned.”
“Athena picked.”
“Jing Wei locked in.”
“Comfort meta pick made it through gg.”
The audience can already see that happening on screen. Your job is explaining what those decisions mean.
- What style of game does this composition want to play?
- Who has pressure early?
- Who scales better?
- Are there comfort picks? Why is it their comfort / what have you seen?
- Target bans? Is it worth it?
- Specific player tendencies?
- What should the audience watch for once the game starts?
This is where the narrative begins. The Balance Between PBP and Color. In draft specifically, the Color Commentator is usually the hard-carry analyst. As the Play-By-Play caster, one of the best things you can do is create breathing room and give your co-caster time to process the draft as it unfolds. The bans are often the perfect time for hypotheticals:
- What might get first picked?
- What is still open?
- What gods fit the current meta?
- What pieces are teams trying to remove?
As picks come through, your job is often more simple than you’d anticipate as a play-by-play. Many times you are primarily:
- relaying the pick
- setting up your co-caster
- keeping pacing smooth
- providing important league or ruleset information
A simple:
“Athena locked in for the blue side” can be all you need before handing things over. That clean transition allows your Color Commentator to immediately start breaking down:
- the purpose of the pick
- synergies
- matchup implications
- win conditions
- player comfort
- draft direction
This process repeats throughout the draft until the final selections come through.
At that point, the roles often temporarily reverse. The Color Commentator may now begin buying time and continuing discussion while production prepares the transition into game. Once the game is ready, the handoff naturally shifts back toward the Play-By-Play caster for introductions and the opening moments of the match.
Handling Delays and Downtime
Broadcast delays happen. Technical issues happen. Pauses happen.
Do not panic and immediately abandon the game conversation unless absolutely necessary.
You can almost always pull discussion from the current draft, the meta, or patch changes. Previously mentioned player tendencies? Dive deeper. Previous sets, league formats, statistics, or predictions for the game ahead. Only fully pivot away from the game once it becomes clear the delay is significant if you are still on air.
And most importantly:
Never throw production under the bus on air. If you do, we have beef now. Congrats.
Production is your teammate. In many ways they are the third caster of the broadcast. Mistakes happen. Technical issues happen. Correct things naturally when possible and keep the show moving professionally.
Predictions and Being Wrong
Predictions are good! Predictions create stakes, direction, and narrative for the audience to follow throughout the game. Do not be afraid to make them. The important thing is avoiding absolutes, unless of course you are a sith. As sith’s famously deal in absolutes.
Leave yourself room to adapt as the game changes. A prediction failing is not bad casting. Sometimes it creates even better storylines once the game begins unfolding differently than expected. If you are unsure about player pronunciations or pronouns, figure it out before going live whenever possible. If you cannot confirm pronouns, default to “they” respectfully and continue the cast naturally. Professionalism in small details matters more than people realize.
Early Game / Establishing Broadcast Rhythm
Now that we are finally in game, let’s establish a few concepts that apply throughout the rest of the cast.
First and foremost: SMITE 2 is still in beta.
That means bugs, pauses, restarts, spectator issues, and weird interactions are going to happen. Depending on the level of broadcast, you also may or may not be instructed to directly address those issues on air.You may be told flat out to ignore even the most obvious. Shout out to that huge wall bug in Season 9.
Either way, your job is to stay calm and professional. If something causes a pause or restart, simple communication is usually enough: “We’ll update you as we know more. We appreciate your patience and apologize for the delay.” Do not panic. Do not speculate wildly. Do not put production on blast.
Mistakes happen. Technical issues happen. Handle them professionally and keep the show moving naturally whenever possible. Another philosophy I learned over time, especially from Aggro, is the idea of not speaking directly on top of the screen as a Color Commentator. You already have a Play-By-Play caster there to handle immediate visible action. As a Color Commentator, ask yourself:
“What can I add here that is more interesting than simply restating what everyone can already see?”
That can mean:
- relic usage expectations
- aspect choices
- pressure building around the map
- player tendencies
- matchup implications
- future fight setups
- scaling
- objective control
The audience can see abilities being cast. Your value often comes from explaining why those moments matter. On the Play-By-Play side, one habit I have personally developed is identifying relics as early and often as possible. Part of that is honestly for myself.
Relics are one of the easiest ways to keep both yourself and the audience grounded in the current state of the game. You never want to be surprised by a Blink, Shell, Sunder, or Purification relic during a major moment because you forgot to establish it beforehand. It also naturally slows your pacing down and helps orient the audience before larger engagements begin. Find your safety net to help build a constant starting line for yourself. And speaking of engagements: be ready immediately.
SMITE 2 can produce invades, level one fights, and chaotic starts before introductions are even complete. Those moments may interrupt your planned flow. Do not treat that like a mistake. Use the surprise. Adapt naturally. Some of the best moments happen specifically because the game interrupted your expectations.
I struggled to find the perfect spot to put this, so I’m going to add it here. As the chair 2 I need you understand now that it’s okay to talk. A lot of new chair 2’s are afraid to hold the microphone too long, but analysis is your role and you feeling it and diving deep is fantastic. The key is finding the right things to dive into. There’s a very delicate balance of using your time as chair 2 as your own the same way your play-by-play holds fights, while also making it a conversation between the two. This where listening to experienced analysts past and present helps significantly. Back to where we were.
Another lesson I cannot stress enough:
Watch the map.
Seriously. The map.
Watch it constantly.
Especially as Play-By-Play, if your Color Commentator is currently speaking, your eyes should almost always be scanning and the inverse does apply.
- the minimap
- health bars
- jungle movement
- lane positioning
- possible rotations
You are constantly searching for where the next important moment might develop before the audience fully realizes it themselves. Strong map awareness dramatically lowers the chances of missing invades, rotations, or early fights. If you consider blaming the camera, ask yourself where you were looking. And if you do miss something?
Do not panic. (Are you seeing a theme?)
You still likely have another twenty or thirty minutes left in the game. Unless the moment was genuinely unbelievable, do not:
- spiral mentally
- overcompensate
- force hype
- apologize endlessly on air
Every caster misses moments sometimes. The important thing is staying honest to the game.
One of the worst habits a caster can develop is trying to force excitement onto moments because they feel they missed something earlier. Trust your instincts. Trust the pace of the match. The audience will forgive a missed moment much faster than they will forgive forced casting.
Mid Game / Letting the Game Speak
By the mid game, the conversations and predictions from the draft and early game should start becoming reality. This is where the cast begins transitioning from “What could happen?” to “What is happening?”
Pressure starts mattering more. Objectives become more meaningful. Rotations tighten up. Players begin grouping more consistently. Small mistakes start creating larger consequences.
And most importantly:
The game itself starts helping tell the story for you.This is where chemistry between casters becomes incredibly important.
Early game naturally provides a lot of structure:
- lane matchups
- starts
- relics
- jungle paths
- pressure discussions
Late game has obvious tension because everyone understands how high the stakes are.
Mid game is where casts can either settle into a great rhythm or completely lose structure.
A huge part of succeeding here is understanding the pace of the lobby you are watching.
Some games are:
- scrappy
- chaotic
- slow
- tense
- methodical
- complete fiestas
Your cast should reflect the game’s energy, not fight against it. One of the biggest mistakes newer casters make is forcing the same level of intensity onto every game regardless of how it is actually unfolding. Be honest to the game you are watching. Not every Gold Fury is game deciding. Not every pick by the blue buff should sound like a world championship moment.
The audience subconsciously trusts you more when your energy feels earned. This is also where the concept of “finding the ball” becomes critical. Mid game SMITE 2 can become visually overwhelming very quickly:
- abilities everywhere
- players entering fights late
- relics being used perfectly and horribly
- split fights happening simultaneously
- objectives burning while carries fight for their lives and their teams
Your job as Play-By-Play is not to cast every particle effect on the screen. Your job is identifying “What is the most important thing happening right now?”
FIND THE FREAKING BALL!
Once you identify the central tension point, the rest of the fight becomes much easier for the audience to follow, easier for your co-caster to follow, and easier for YOU to follow.
If everything is treated equally important, nothing feels important. This is also the stage of the game where setup becomes just as important as payoff.
Not every blink forward means:
“OH MY GOD HERE WE GO.”
Experienced casters learn to recognize the difference between:
- posturing
- poke
- baiting
- scouting
- actual commitment
Just like players do, one of the hardest skills to learn as Play-By-Play is pacing your own escalation. If you begin every fight at maximum intensity, going back to our energy levels, you leave yourself nowhere to build toward once the truly important moments happen. Sometimes the tension before the fight matters more than the first few seconds of the fight itself.
Let moments breathe.
Build anticipation.
Then accelerate once the game truly demands it. Another important skill during mid game is learning how to recover after fights cleanly. A lot of newer broadcasts have strong fight calls followed by awkward silence or both casters trying to talk over each other immediately afterward.
Once the major action settles:
- reset the audience
- recap the important moment
- identify what changed
- discuss relics burned
- discuss objective implications
- reconnect the moment back to earlier narratives from the game
This is often where the Color Commentator thrives again after a heavy Play-By-Play sequence. Do not become discouraged if fights become messy or difficult to follow. SMITE 2 is chaotic. Observers will occasionally miss things. You will occasionally miss things. Your co-caster will occasionally miss things.
That is normal. The audience is not expecting perfection. What they are expecting is confidence, composure, and a cast that helps them understand the important moments as naturally as possible.
LATE GAME BABY! + Let’s talk details
Before we dive into the most exciting part, where the play-by plays get their clips and the color commentators get their “I told you so” moments, let’s look at the relationship between the two of you.
Working With Your Co-Caster
This is everything. No ifs, ands, or buts about it. Your cast is only as good as you both make it. You both succeed and fail in the same places. I simply do not care if it is your worst enemy on the other headset, while the game is going on that is your ride or die. You oooo where they ahh. If your co-caster gets lost, do not “correct” them publicly or make the moment awkward. I promise you, the number one thing that will be your cast killer, drive the audience to mute you, and people to go to the next channel faster than almost anything else, aside from perhaps enough negativity, is two casters who are all over each other and clearly miserable working together. So let’s go back to if your other chair gets lost during a game. Because as newer casters it will happen eventually.
Help guide them naturally:
- Ask follow-up questions.
- Bring them back to points they were making.
- Ask about synergies.
- Ask about matchups.
- Give them space to recover their train of thought.
One of my favorite techniques as a Play-By-Play caster is intentionally approaching situations from a newer player perspective, or even occasionally presenting a slightly flawed thought process to allow the Color Commentator room to explain or softly correct it.
That does two things:
- It helps newer viewers understand the game
- It allows your co-caster opportunities to showcase their knowledge naturally
A cast should feel collaborative, not competitive.
If you are a chair 2 looking for some easy layups to your play-by-play, get them into big fights early, gas up their hype, and help them find the ball if you think they are getting stuck. I call these adlibs, some call them pop offs, but simply pointing out the Thor in the air, or the blink from the jungler can get a play-by-play back on track. Don’t steal the moment, highlight the ball.
LATE GAME!
This is where it all comes together. You worked towards this. Now to make it worth the wait and build. Alright you cute little chair 1. Grab the mic — it is time.
By late game everybody understands what is happening now. Builds are online, fights matter, objectives matter, one bad death can completely flip the game and every player in the lobby can FEEL it. This is where Play-By-Play really gets to shine.
But while you’re calling fights, do not forget you are still part of a duo.
One of the biggest things to learn late game is cadence and timing. As you’re calling fights, there needs to be a natural rhythm that tells your Color Commentator:
“Alright I’m done for the moment, pick it up.”
And CC, same thing applies back. Nobody wants to get talked over for thirty minutes straight. Find clean ways to hand conversations back and forth naturally. To reference one of my favorite points I’ve heard from Aggro — he tries to make sure every sentence has an escape or drop word and he speaks. That way he never drops late. This will always be harder remotely but that is part of the game. Your play-by-play also needs to understand we don’t need to hold the mic the whole late game. Do not fight for recaps, you have an analyst. Don’t try to build your own tension by the phoenixes. Your chair 2 should help build that. A lot of the skills of late game casting come from experience so I am purposefully not diving too deep here.
That said — read the room.
If a huge fight is clearly about to happen and your CC is still talking about an item’s passive for the last forty seconds without setting you up, don’t be shocked if you have to shoulder check your way back onto the cast. The game comes first. CHAIR 1’s. IF YOU ARE STILL YAPPIN’ AND THEY HAVEN’T FOUGHT FOR A MINUTE drop the damn microphone. Save your voice and your breath and be ready to take over. WATCH THE MAP and trust your co-caster.
Late game casting is all about time management.
Seriously.
TIME.
TIME.
TIME.
Just like
MAP.
MAP
MAP.
One of the biggest mistakes newer play-by-play casters make is starting too high too early. ENERGY LEVELS. One of my favorite pieces of advice I think of every cast is from Hinduman. You may think you need your energy level to max at 10 for a penta kill, but what happens if there are two penta kills?
You see players grouping and immediately start screaming before anything has even happened yet. Then by the time the ACTUAL fight starts you are already out of breath, your energy is fried, and your CC hates you because there’s nowhere left to build.
Read the scene.
Sometimes slowing down actually creates MORE tension.
If both teams are dancing around Fire Giant and everyone knows one blink could start the game deciding fight, let that pressure build naturally. Use shorter sentences. Slow your pacing down a little. Let the audience feel the moment before you explode into it.
Not every engagement is immediately real either. Players posture. They bait. They fake pressure constantly late game trying to force relics or positioning mistakes. Learn the difference between “this fight MIGHT happen” and “oh, this is happening RIGHT NOW.”
That pacing matters a ton.
And when the real fight finally breaks out? Commit to it. Trust your instincts and go.
This matters the most during titan sieges and game ending pushes. Obviously the throne room as well. Read the end with patience and don’t deal in absolutes— we aren’t sith. Wait for your moment then STRIKE.
Nobody remembers the caster who got excited too early.
People absolutely remember the caster who missed the game ending moment entirely.
And once the game finally DOES end, the color commentator needs to read your energy. If you can’t match or think silence should sit - give it a beat. Give the breakdowns and give your chair 1 time to recover and get back in. Chair 1’s AND 2’s don’t just instantly vanish. Work on your sign off. Thank your co-caster, thank production, mention upcoming games, tell people where to follow the league, or join the discord. Doesn’t need to sound corporate. Just make it yours.
That final thirty seconds is still part of the broadcast. Don’t overdo it, because people will leave quickly. Do your job, mention what you gotta mention and then wrap it up and go home.
I have more to yap about so thank you for reading so far and I hope this step by step of the game helps you.
Skills: Tone, Pitch, Energy, Technical Yoohaha.
This is where things can get preachy, but going over this and being conscious of it will make your life easier, and make you a better caster in the long run. Watch this video. Jorby sent it to me and it is a life saver and game changer. https://youtu.be/r_gErA6KHag?si=c8au9Ghq7l-11f2-
Using Your Voice
Even if you have the coolest voice ever from birth, you need to control it. If you have one you think is horrible, proper technique can make it amazing.
- Just like real life, tone sets your mood and the vibe for everything to follow. You do not HAVE to use a different voice/ tone to cast, but you should be making an effort to put your best voice forward. If you sound even the slightest bit disinterested, I promise you it WILL come across to the viewers. This means being aware of yawns, sniffles, and those types of noises. This can also transfer all the way to words. We all have filler words that we use, but when you are casting, the more you can limit the use of ALL filler words, “like, um, uh” (those three are the most important to get rid of), or leaving a lot of empty space between you and your CC, and anything similar the better. That is the number one way to cause a viewer to think less of you as a caster. It sounds harsh, but that one cannot be avoided. One or two sneaking through cracks or you getting caught slipping is not the end of the world. Using something like “UHHHH” as a set up is obviously different, but you need to be as conscious as possible to avoid these words and phrases, or lack thereof.
- You have the ability to tell a story with every new fight and moment using nothing more than your volume, tone, range, and emotion. Imagine the best casters you have ever heard— esports, trad sports, doesn’t matter. Then imagine the WORST. Can you remember the emotions that came from the best? How their voices and feelings transcended the screen and hit you? That is your goal. All of this applies to not only the PxP but to CC. Everyone needs to be at their best to give their best. Plain and simple.
- Let’s talk about hype and overall excitement for BOTH the PxP & CC. A small mistake that can be made is if your PxP just walked you and the audience through something amazing. Energy is a scale. 1-10. If they hit a 9, and they borderline shattered their microphone there are now a couple of truths. The PxP should try to bring that energy down at a smooth outro that is easy to match. The CC should go up in energy to match their co-caster. If your chair 1 drops at an 8, you should at least TRY to pick up at a 6, if not 7.
- Casting has MANY different styles. Each caster I named is unique. Other esports have their goats who are unique. Don’t force it and do not replicate. Howard Stern at one point in time was the #1 radio host in America, LOVED for his show but also his voice. When he started, he used a fake corny radio voice that did not work. He started using his normal speaking voice just with a clearer and slower tonality and instantly became a success. Consider this when you cast. If casting too quickly makes you stutter or get lost, or casting too loud makes you lose breath or you are not understood, find what works for you. The most important thing the PxP is doing is telling us HOW. The CC handles WHY. So call what you see when you can and tell the story as you see it. I’d rather hear you say ten beautifully called words then 45 pieces of gibberish. Don’t be afraid to be wrong or make a mistake. Just focus on giving it your all YOUR way. We will work on what that means for you.
How Can I Practice?
Here is my response. How did you learn video games? By playing. Cast. Cast as much as you can. Go over VODs and listen to yourself to find what worked and what didn’t. “But I hate my voice on recordings.” That is something you simply have to get over because otherwise you cannot and will not get better. It is not easy, and most of the best casters to have walked on this planet also hate their voice. My counter is aside from the honesty I just shared. If you want hundreds if not thousands of people to listen to your voice, you NEED to be able to get through a VOD of your own as well.
Expand your vocabulary, listen to a variety of other casters. It doesn’t matter the game. Listen for how they get through things, how they save stumbles, how they get you invested. GET FEEDBACK. Reach out to strong and established casters to see if they will go over your VODs or give advice. The worst they can say is no. Remember, at the end of the day we are the backing track not the stars of the show.
Finally, have fun and create chemistry with the other casters. That will make everything else ez game ez life. I can promise you that.
“I ain’t reading all that, happy for you. Or sorry that happened”
Thanks for reading,
